What do you expect "standard_unix_corp-cis_shared"+"standard_unix_corp-cis_shared" to give? You shouldn't be adding all the fields together.

foreach my $index (0..$#line)
should be something like
foreach my $index (4,5)

By the way,
$servers{$name} = [@line];
needlessly copies @line. Simply use
$servers{$name} = \@line;
since my @line; will create a new var for you every pass.