Well, then you either live among hypocrites or you think everyone is "extremely rude". Saying something bad about someone is quite often simply TRUE

Rudeness is how something is said, not what is said.

"Shut the fuck up" is a command, so I don't see how it can be true (or false).

That would be experience.

Prejudice based on experience is still prejudice.

No one said all Indians are stupid or lazy,

"Only Indians are stupid or lazy" is equally racist.

And not only is it unclear what did those monks agree with, but more importantly there were only five of them

I already corrected my post to account for the first half, but I disagree with the second half. I'm sure more than 5 monks viewed the consideration in 6 hours, and not a single one voted to keep.