in reply to Re: Weird quoting with /x modifier
in thread Weird quoting with /x modifier

Interesting addition:
With the following code:
use strict; use warnings; my $teststring = qq/Hello# World/; my $regex1 = qr{\QHello# World\E}x; my $regex2 = qr{Hello\#\ World}x; my $regex3 = qr{$teststring}x; my $regex4 = qr{\Q$teststring\E}x; print "String is $teststring\n"; print "Regex1 is $regex1\n"; print "Regex2 is $regex2\n"; print "Regex3 is $regex3\n"; print "Regex4 is $regex4\n";
I get the following output (perl 5.12.1):
String is Hello# World Regex1 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World\\E) Regex2 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World) Regex3 is (?x-ism:Hello# World ) Regex4 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World)
For regex3, the newline is inserted by the qr directive, as verified by a hex dump of the file.

UPDATE:
Output from perl 5.8.9:

$ perl8 regex.pl String is Hello# World Regex1 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World\\E ) Regex2 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World ) Regex3 is (?x-ism:Hello# World ) Regex4 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World )
Output from perl 5.10.1:
$ perl10 regex.pl String is Hello# World Regex1 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World\\E) Regex2 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World) Regex3 is (?x-ism:Hello# World ) Regex4 is (?x-ism:Hello\#\ World)
So, it looks like there may be an edge case that was partially fixed.

UPDATE 2: clarified that initial tests were on 5.12.1
This is perl 5, version 12, subversion 1 (v5.12.1) built for x86_64-linux-thread-multi-ld
This is perl, v5.10.1 (*) built for x86_64-linux-thread-multi-ld
This is perl, v5.8.9 built for x86_64-linux-thread-multi-ld