in reply to Re: (tye)Re3: Extract potentially quoted words
in thread Extract potentially quoted words

Fine, I ammend my statement from:

Although in Perl, most statements can also be used as expressions, there are a few exceptions.
to
Although in Perl, most statements can also be used as expressions (so long as you drop the final ";", if there happens to be one there), there are a few exceptions.
so you can be happy with your definition of the word "statement". I'll leave the original wording in place for historical reasons (and because it is easier to understand, for most people).

There are too many cases where the semicolon is optional in Perl so I don't consider the semicolon as being part of the statement. You give a good example of why the semicolon isn't strictly just a statement separator either. But whether the semicolon is required has more to do with things outside the statement than the statement itself, so I find it hard to consider it as an integral part of the statement. I still think of it as being used to separate statements, it just isn't always required to separate statements. I find both points of view equally valid.

What a silly argument. q-:

        - tye (but my friends call me "Tye")
  • Comment on (tye)Re4: Extract potentially quoted words