in reply to Re^3: Reference to guard not released
in thread Reference to guard not released
I don't want to protect $x. I just want to touch $x (store the value into it) when Scope::Guard object gets destroyed, i.e. when all references to it go out of scope.
In simple and obvious example below, the $g gets destroyed and inner sub called immediately after it goes out of scope.
use strict; use Scope::Guard; my $x; { my $g = Scope::Guard->new(sub {$x; warn "destroyed"}); } warn "end";
But I checked, and putting braces around the dcl of $x, doesn't change the output. So I would bet scopeguard has stored a reference to the interior sub so it can be called when "$x" goes out of scope.
Your bet is wrong. The sub is called the guard gets destroyed, not the object it references. Look at the Scope::Guard code. Is very short and self explanatory.
All you did by assigning undef to $code is lose the reference to the outside sub.. SGnew still has a reference to the inner sub and $x...
Yes, but when I lose reference to the outside sub, I should also lose the last reference to $g, because the sub is the only object which sees $g. But it doesnot happen.
Does that make more sense?
I need to read comments above, but it still doesnot make more sense to me. However constructed is the inner sub (stored in $g) it is just another object referenced by $g, not referencing it. So I don't understand how it (the inner sub) can affect the reference count to $g.
The example I gave doesnot make sense itself, it is just the simplest demonstration of the behaviour I was able to make up. My original was more like the test below: ($x is \@res, I just try to log into res, when the object gets destroyed).
use strict; use Test::More tests=>2; use Scope::Guard; sub try { my @res; my @subs = do { my $g; ( sub { push @res, 'a'; $g = Scope::Guard->new( sub { warn "destroyed"; push @res, 'destroyed' } ); }, sub { push @res, 'b'; undef $g; } ); }; ( shift @subs )->(); is_deeply( \@res, ['a'] ); undef @subs; is_deeply( \@res, [ 'a', 'destroyed' ] ); } try();
|
|---|