in reply to Helping Makefile Find Locally Installed Prerequisite Module

Do you just need to have the path to the local module in your PERL5LIB environment variable? Or you can specify the other path when running the Makefile.PL. According to perldoc ExtUtils::MakeMaker (the thing that Makefile.PLs use to produce the makefiles):
perl Makefile.PL LIB=/path/to/lib_directory/