in reply to Re: Why isn't this regex greedy?
in thread Why isn't this regex greedy?

Its pretty well the same thing as
Well, you might want to point out how it's different. Laziness is a tendency, not a mandate. Adding a trailing "Q" to both regex shows the difference:
"fooXbarYbarQ" =~ /(foo)(.{1,5}?)barQ/ # match entire string
will match, skipping over the first bar because it's not followed by Q. However, the previous regex, followed by a Q will fail:
"fooXbarYbarQ" =~ /(foo)(((?!bar).){1,5})barQ/ # won't match
because it can't "skip over" the first bar to get to the second one.

So, while lazy is good, it's not the only game in town, and you have to consider the rest of the regex before you know you can get away with lazy instead of inchworm.

-- Randal L. Schwartz, Perl hacker
Be sure to read my standard disclaimer if this is a reply.