in reply to Inner subroutines?

Effectively, that code is identical to this:

use strict; use warnings; use 5.010; use feature qw(say); sub inner_sub { my $param = shift; say "Start inner_sub1"; return ++$param; } sub outer_sub { say "Outer Subroutine Start ..."; my $param = 0; say "PARAM: $param"; $param = inner_sub($param); say "PARAM: $param"; say "Outer Subroutine End."; } # Main outer_sub(); exit(0); __END__ [22:16:28.33] c:\test>junk41 Outer Subroutine Start ... PARAM: 0 Start inner_sub1 PARAM: 1 Outer Subroutine End.

The fact that inner_sub() is enclosed in outer_sub() makes no difference to its visibility:

use strict; use warnings; use 5.010; use feature qw(say); sub outer_sub { say "Outer Subroutine Start ..."; my $param = 0; say "PARAM: $param"; $param = inner_sub($param); say "PARAM: $param"; say "Outer Subroutine End."; sub inner_sub { my $param = shift; say "Start inner_sub1"; return ++$param; } } # Main outer_sub(); inner_sub(); ### Visible here also! exit(0); __END__ [22:20:34.37] c:\test>junk41 Outer Subroutine Start ... PARAM: 0 Start inner_sub1 PARAM: 1 Outer Subroutine End. Start inner_sub1

But, declaring nested sub is "dangerous" in that it can result in closures that don't work properly like this:

use strict; use warnings; use 5.010; use feature qw(say); sub outer_sub { my $scoped_var = 'fred'; ## closure say "Outer Subroutine Start ..."; my $param = 0; say "PARAM: $param"; $param = inner_sub($param); say "PARAM: $param"; say "Outer Subroutine End."; sub inner_sub { my $param = shift; say "Start inner_sub1"; say $scoped_var; ## closure return ++$param; } } # Main outer_sub(); inner_sub(); exit(0); __END__ [22:22:00.66] c:\test>junk41 Variable "$scoped_var" will not stay shared at C:\test\junk41.pl line +20. Outer Subroutine Start ... PARAM: 0 Start inner_sub1 fred PARAM: 1 Outer Subroutine End. Start inner_sub1 fred

Though I forget the circumstances in which the "Variable "$scoped_var" will not stay shared " actually causes a problem. I think it's been possible to declare inner subs for a long time, certainly as long as I've been using Perl, but AFAIK, there is no good reason for doing so, and it can--though I forget the circumstances because I never do it--cause problems.


Examine what is said, not who speaks -- Silence betokens consent -- Love the truth but pardon error.
"Science is about questioning the status quo. Questioning authority".
In the absence of evidence, opinion is indistinguishable from prejudice.