in reply to Geek registry

I don't want to sound pompous, but why don't you just accept whatever gifts people want to give you, and then hand off the stuff you don't want/need to some worthy charity? I'm sure Oxfam pr Save The Children could use whatever you offer. This not only saves all the effort, but also has the side benefit of allowing you to feel good about yourselves for a bit.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
(kudra: unwanted stuff is wasteful no matter who gets it) RE: RE: Geek registry
by kudra (Vicar) on Aug 01, 2000 at 15:21 UTC
    When people visit, they are sometimes hurt if they don't see their gift in use. When you say "I gave it away," they won't all be happy to hear it. Being honest about what you want--be it something for yourself or a donation to a charity--prevents the accumulation of junk. Can Oxfam really use 20 espresso makers and a dozen clocks, or might it be better served by a donation which allows it to purchase whatever supplies are needed? Also, he wouldn't be limited in his choice of charities if he requested donations. And why is it wrong for him to request things he wants, which he intends to purchase anyway? That has the end result of one item being purchased instead of two (less packaging waste, etc).

    -kudra, who prefers donations in her name go to EFF, ACLU or NOW

RE: RE: Geek registry
by tye (Sage) on Aug 01, 2000 at 18:14 UTC

    If going to an event where bringing a gift is traditional and/or expected, many people will appreciate being able to see what gifts are most desired and also what gifts have already been selected by someone else. Buying a gift can be quite a challenge and the assistance in choosing one is welcomed by some people in some situations.

    If you already know what you'd like to give as a gift (perhaps because you know the person(s) especially well), then don't look at the registry. I really doubt the recipient is going to be upset that you didn't buy a gift from "the list".

    The point of a registry is not to claim that these are the only things that you'd appreciate as gifts, but to help people choose a gift that they know will be appreciated if they want that help.

    And I doubt Oxfam or Save The Children wants a toaster or a fondue set. Unless the gift came with a receipt (unlikely), they aren't going to be able to get much (if any) money for it -- especially subtracting the time required.

    The thought just makes me giggle. "Hungry children all over the world have plenty of bread, but are forced to toast it over clumsy camp fires, often burning it. But you can help. We have plenty of gasoline and generators for them, but we desperately need more electric toasters. Please send your generous donation today!". Sorry, I couldn't resist.